Online shopping: what are the innovations in product search / comparison?
Message from Jeremy: To all Tech IT Easy readers, who could obviously not necessarily remember the initial announcement, I have invited Fidji Simo to write about web strategies and provide you with insights on how to manage and develop small & medium businesses. Fidji’s mission statement is that there’s no mission statement: what matters most is to start nice conversations and have fun.
It will surprise nobody that, for the first article written by a woman on Tech IT Easy, I will speak about online shopping, and especially about how to find and compare products online.
The fact that search engines are becoming the entry gate for any search on the Internet gives them a competitive advantage with the growth in online shopping, as customers use them also as product search engines.
That is why a lot of shopping comparators are becoming click brokers: they invest a lot in Adwords to attract customers who start their product search on Google, and then display a lot of Adsense on their pages (just next to product flow) to convert the maximum of visitors into clickers. No major comparator can avoid it, as none of them have managed to create brand loyalty, not even Kelkoo which sees its organic traffic decreasing.
But this type of monetization tends to provide a bad user experience: traditional shopping comparators (or price comparators in this case) just do not manage to reinvent themselves.
The question to ask is: which service would you really like to use when you look for a product? What is still missing in the market?
I will focus on three major trends which will probably force the giants of product search / comparison to innovate at a higher rhythm: visual, social and mobile shopping.
A few weeks ago, in the South of France, I saw a beautiful sofa with coloured pillows in the window of a closed shop. Nothing was there to indicate the brand of the sofa, so I just took a picture. I tried to search “sofa with coloured pillows” on Google and Shopping.com (an eBay company, so I show some loyalty!), and of course you can guess that I did not manage to find my sofa. But with Like.com (US product search engine) I would have found it immediately: indeed, you just have to upload your picture of a specific object and the picture is considered as a query. Then Like.com browses its database to help you find products with a similar graphic signature. And finally, here is my sofa! If you fall in love with Cameron Diaz’s purse (screenshot in this article) without knowing the designer, you can search for similar purses thanks to a picture of it.
Visual shopping is expected to boom in the years to come: in France, Shopoon (PPR group) is planning to launch a visual application based on LTU technology.
But you do not always run into a beautiful sofa; sometimes, the best way to find an amazing product is to have a friend recommending one. This is the trend of social shopping. It has started in France with Ciao! including customers’ advice on products, but new models tend to leverage even more the influence of other customers / friends. But the problem with models like Zlio (you create your own shop to sell your products, essentially to friends) or Xinek (you get a commission when a friend buy a product you have recommended) is that they erase the basement of social shopping: basically, you rely on friends or other customers because they have no interest in selling a special product, which is exactly not the case in those models! So I think that the future on social shopping will be based on websites ranking products according to customers’ satisfaction (Vozavi) and specs (Looneo) or on crawlers aggregating all the available content of a product (Wikio Shopping, if they improve their crawler).
Finally, people (especially women!) who search for good bargains would love to compare prices and specs even when they are shopping offline. Htfacile has launched in France a mobile comparator service: you enter on your mobile the bar code of a product when you are at the supermarket and it returns the 3 cheapest prices found on the Internet. In the US, Slifter goes further: you can now take a picture of the bar code with your mobile, and Slifter returns the best prices for this product both online and offline in your specific location. If the best price can be found in a store in your geographic area, Slifter gives you the map to go to this store on your mobile! I don’t know if I would use it for everyday purchases, but for expensive products it would definitely save me some time and money! In terms of business model, it increases the number of opportunities to use shopping comparators, and revenues for those applications at the same time.
According to market researches, people would like to have a shopping hub where they can find all the shopping-related services. Personally, I would love to have those 3 trends in one: take a picture with my camera phone, get a list of matching products on my mobile with customers’ advice!
And you, how would you like to find, compare and choose products online?
Related posts:












Hey Fidji,
You’re perfectly right to bring a “Back to Skinny Jeans” (http://cravingideas.blogs.com/) atmosphere on Tech IT Easy. We needed that badly.
I love PPR’s Shopoon too. I believe it’s a great website that deserves a faster take off. When you say it’s getting ready to launch a visual app based on LTU, do you mean the French start up that does image recognition & search? It’s one of the few survivors the first Internet bubble burst, and I heard it’s a really good company.
I think Zlio & Xinek, both founded by very experienced web entrepreneurs (Berrebi & Eskenazi) & marketing experts have lots of potential as well.
Looneo isn’t bad either. I predict it will be a huge success actually.
Do you know Yoox? It’s one of my favourite eCommerce websites: http://jeremyfain.wordpress.com/2007/01/03/yoox-an-e-commerce-website-reproducing-a-brick-and-mortar-shopping-experience/
And here are the other fashion eCommerce sites I like (since we’re back in skinny jeans…) on top of Shopoon & Yoox:
Rush Collection
eLuxury
Blue Fly
NetaPorter
Next
Asos
What do you think of these?
Concerning LTU, you are perfectly right, and it has developped an umbeatable expertise in visual search. For the moment, most of websites (including Shopoon) pretend doing visual search when they just allow users to look at images and select them, whereas the LTU application will allow a more proactive search by uploading a picture to find a match (such as Like.com).
Concerning Yoox, I can’t agree more, the most important in online product search is at least to reproduce the same process of choice as offline shopping. But it is even better when it can provide more: I recommend you http://www.blackdogair.com/ which is based on Amazon API: as if you were in Fnac, you select your category, but after that, for each book you click on, the website suggests you related books with a “search tree”.
Finally, among the websites you have mentioned, I particularly appreciate eLuxury, as it tackles a real need of finding luxury brands (which more often want to keep an impression of scarcity) without deteriorating brand images.
Thx girl, it’s good to have an online shopping expert at last on this blog. Let’s try to get away from the geeky attitude.
Just to answer your question in your post: I’d like to find, choose & compare products online in a 3D environment.
So actually you must love youarethemodel.com! Unfortunately I haven’t met Benjamin at HEC, but the application is amazing, I have even presented it at eBay, you can tell him!
Btw, I have a little geek side too: I have spent my whole afternoon looking at the demos of Microsoft Surface, it is just awesome, I was kind of jealous to think that you are working in such an innovative company…!!
So, join us if you’re so jealous. The door is opened.
About FittingBox / YouAreTheModel (it’s not 3D!): feel free to contact him on my behalf and tell him you’d like him to present @ eBay. I’m sure there are a thousand applications of the FittingBox technology @ eBay.
Concerning the 3D thing, it is the possibility of seeing the glasses in 3D I was talking about, even if the rest of the application is not 3D: http://fr.techcrunch.com/2007/04/13/coup-doeil-sur-youarethemodel/