7 reasons why I'm stopping using Last.fm for music & 4 reasons why I'm starting to use Drop.io + Facebook Connect

I love musicMy sentiments about online media aside (I think it’s despicable the way media-companies treat consumers, particularly outside of the US), it has always bothered me to use Last.fm for a number of reasons. Here they are:

  1. Last.fm, apart from being happy to pull my listening data into their site, does not integrate with my listening habits Whats.O.Ever. My method for managing music, perhaps determined by owning an iPod, is entirely dominated by iTunes and the usage of the device itself.

  2. Last.fm does not play on the road (let’s ignore the iPhone radio app and that eventually all devices will be connected to the internet)

  3. Last.fm does not acknowledge that I give different stars (= degrees of love) to songs (instead I have to “love” a song manually).

  4. Discovering new music through Last.fm’s radio does not easily lead me to purchase the actual song

  5. One cherry on top is that Last.fm now wants to charge me for using the radio, even though I add to it by playing my songs.

  6. A second cherry on top is that Last.fm is now, indirectly through CBS, giving information about what we listen to and who we are, to the RIAA, a US organisation that probably also shares that information with other international organisations.

  7. The only use Last.fm seems to have is vanity, in the sense that you can see what songs I loved (when I love them) and I can make pretty graphics of my listening habits (makes for an interesting poster).

So, as of this week, I am deleting my Last.fm account.

That doesn’t change that I am a fervent listener of music and it also doesn’t change that I believe deeply in the concept of sharing music. I like finding nice tracks to play at parties and equally I like finding tracks for some of my friends that I can only connect to online. There is no legal service that allows me to do this. As a matter of fact, in the Netherlands, I should even be paying a licensing fee if I play music in public or for too many people at once!!!

In comes Drop.io, a file-sharing service that recently added Facebook Connect as a way to share stuff only with your friends. Drop.io fills the void that Last.fm leaves in the following ways:

  1. It has an integrated player that is very elegant and can also be accessed and added to via many different devices.

  2. I can restrict access to my files to my Facebook friends only (evil internet lawyers can get lost).

  3. It’s free for using 100 MB storage and charges a very fair $10 per gigabyte per year.

  4. Any loss in statistical “vanity” data can be compensated by using iTunes and starring / sorting your files accordingly.

That’s it. Of course I will not be sharing songs that are copyright protected (and, of course, if we’re not Facebook connected, you will never know for sure ;) )

Vincent

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

2 Responses to “7 reasons why I'm stopping using Last.fm for music & 4 reasons why I'm starting to use Drop.io + Facebook Connect”

  1. I’ve struggled with last.fm’s use-case, mostly because of the same reasons you have. iTunes’ Genius was the last straw for me, even though it has some inherent problems with music not in iTunes Music Store.

    About point 6, though, Last.fm has quite aggressively denied that it has disclosed personal information to third parties. Of course, what last.fm’s users listen to has been available for pretty much anyone all the time (it being public with the APIs and all) so that shouldn’t really be news. Techcrunch is just talking probably out of their ass about leaking personal information part, because if last.fm really did that they would be pretty much in violation of EU Data Privacy laws.

  2. (hmm tried to replied via mail, it didn’t work… Here’s my comment again.)

    Contrary to many people perhaps, I actually trust Techcrunch to report the news as best as they can. It has gained a status of notoriety for reasons unknown to me and commentators on that site are what I would call Digg-people, but I do think they have a stake in reporting accurate news. Of course, with neither CBS, nor Last.fm commenting, we will probably never know for certain.

    Also, since CBS is a US-company, I assume that the data (IF) released concerns US citizens. Nevertheless, having experienced, first- and second-hand, the behaviour of both the Dutch and German RIAA-counterparts, I am certain that any such data is being collected and passed on to European instutions also.

    Of course, this whole argument (point 6) is moot if Techcrunch is actually wrong. I don’t believe it is in this case and was already very surprised how much leeway Last.fm was getting from CBS after the acquisition.

Staypressed theme by Themocracy