A thought about comment-enticement
Comments on this blog? No, not many, and I know I’m not alone either. Another blogger thought that the main casualty of Twitter isn’t blogging, but actually commenting. We alluded to something similar a few years ago, when Kari and me both wrote blog posts on where the conversation was going. Ironically, back then, we did get comments, but my conclusion was that comments were moving towards more specialised platforms, like Digg, Slashdot, and now Friendfeed, and maybe Twitter.
Back when I followed 300 people on Twitter you couldn’t pay me enough to read my Twitter-stream. I called it trying to drink from a waterfall several times and you all know what happens when you drink from a waterfall: you fall in!
No, the only way I read Twitter content and pretty much the best way to catch my attention these days is to @vincentvw me, just because I have an rss-feed just for that.
The traditional, “writing for success” way? Write a compelling title. But that has back-fired on me as a reader more than once. You can also write posts to p*ss off people, which is pretty effective, but leads to stuff like death threats.
I like the idea of pinging someone personally, à la the Twitter reply, much more. What I would like is something as follows:
A system that gives people the option to register with their names, contact-details, and interests (in the form of tags, maybe). And when, and only when, that particular interest is being written about, then you get pinged.
I guess you could already do this with some fancy Google tracking or just by subscribing to a tag-based rss-feed (Delicious allows for this, not sure about other platforms). But I see this as a great way for blogs to become relevant once more. It would also force bloggers to connect more with their readers’ interests and perhaps lead to a stronger community feel.
What do you think?
Vincent
(Picture, called “Emptiness is form,” is courtesy of Scott Snibbe.)











In our ever-continuing tradition of trying to serve our readers better, we're now try to entice more comments by using Disqus instead of Wordpress' own commenting. Sure, technology alone isn't a solution, but it should help facilitate a better discussion.
Indeed, I look forward to re-reading your and my comment on Friendfeed, Twitter, http://techiteasyblog.disqus.com/a_thought_abou... and whatever else Disqus is pumping this content towards
As for more conversation… you're right, technology isn't everything. Let's keep on keepin' on.
first comment on commenting : commenting itself is a healthy indicator that internet and it's philosophy works right.
I think that you resumed it very strongly in the comment this time “let's keep keeping on”
But you aren't using disqus. Do you think intenseDebate is better than disqus?
Difficult to say what's the situation today, but intenseDebate did at least integrate better with Wordpress than Disqus. At the time, DIsqus' comment moderation was a mess, but they have since updated the whole site so it might work these days.